Real Images with Ground Truth

Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering Novel light 1 Novel light 2
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
GT
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering Novel light 1 Novel light 2
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
GT
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering Novel light 1 Novel light 2
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
GT
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering Novel light 1 Novel light 2
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
GT

Real Images without Ground Truth

Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb
Input
Normal Diffuse Roughness Specular Rendering
[Deschaintre18]
[Deschaintre19]
[Gao19]+
Ours syn
Ours hyb